Effectiveness of Play
Therapy in Reducing Postoperative Pain among Children (2-5 yrs) in Selected Pediatric
Hospitals Madurai
Mrs. M. Vijaya
Reader, CSI Jeyaraj
Annapackiam College of Nursing, Madurai.
*Corresponding Author Email:
ABSTRACT:
Aim: This study determined the effectiveness of play therapy in
reducing post operative pain among children (2-5 yrs) in selected paediatric hospitals, Madurai. Method: Qualitative research
approach was adopted. Tool comprised of 2 items. Part one included
socio-demographic variables and part two included FLACC behavioural
pain assessment scale - the acronym FLACC represents five categories namely
face, leg, activity, cry, consolability. The pain was
assessed using observation method. Responses in each category are scored
between 0 and 2 for a maximum total score of 10. Results: The data were
collected from 30 children. Majority of the children experienced moderate level
of pain before play therapy and mild pain after play therapy. No significant
association was found between post operative pain and the demographic
variables. Conclusion: The findings concluded that majority of children
experienced mild pain after play therapy. Hence play therapy is effective in
reducing the post operative pain.
KEY
WORDS:
INTRODUCTION:
“Work while you work and play while you
play
That is the way to be happy and gay”.
Play is one
of the most important aspects in a child’s life; it is the universal language
of children. Play allows children to learn social behaviour, develop cognitive
abilities as well as gross and fine motor skills and to work through emotional
conflict.
The hospital
is an unfamiliar environment and hospitalization is the frightening experience
to a child. Play is one of the effective tools for overcoming stress. Play is
essential for sick children. The child
can express his feelings and aggressions through a play and thereby reduces the
trauma caused by hospitalization. Play activity with children allows nurses to
make a significant and warm relationship with the child, which generates ease
and security and lays the foundation for a close and trusting relationship
between the child and the nurse.
Relief of
pain and discomfort is a major nursing intervention, the nurses play a pivotal
role in kindly observing the child, to determine the play needs and provide
play material.
Hospitalized
children require more than recreational play because illness and hospitalisation constitute crisis in a child’s life and
since these situations are fraught with over whelming stresses children need to
play out the fears and anxiety as a means of coping with these stresses. Play
also helps to divert their mind from pain and loneliness (Beryl Juliet Sam,
2000’s).
This study
was aimed to determine the effect of play on the reduction of post operative
pain experienced by children. This would help the nurse to learn to assess the
nature and intensity of pain and manage it appropriately. It would also
indicate the effectiveness of play therapy in the reduction of post operative
pain. It will indicate the necessity of using play as diversion and helping the
child cope with, so that the memory of hospitalisation
will be a pleasant one.
LITERATURE REVIEW:
Bindu
Khurana (2000) stated that when play is used for therapeutic purpose it is called play
therapy. This term is based upon the fact that play is a child’s natural medium
of self expression. Play is an important diagnostic instrument too. The
selection and rejection of a particular play material is significant in the
diagnosis of the disorder.
Lahes
(1998) study supported the use of
puppet shows as therapeutic play to decrease anxiety in hospitalized
preschoolers.
Clatworthys study demonstrated that the therapeutic play is a
valuable intervention with the hospitalized children.
D’antonio IJ. Stated
that play can be a tool to understand and
intervene with paediatric patients with emotional and
cognitive growth promoting activities which facilitate more positive hospital
experience and long term out come.
Lara J. Spagrud et al., (2003) Study
suggested that the faces pain scale Revise (FPS – R) is a useful self report
tool for assessing pain intensity in preschool and school age children who may
not be able to use other pediatric self report pain measurement tools, such as
Visual Analog or numeric rating scales.
METHOD:
Qualitative
research approach was adopted. Pre experimental design – One group Pre-test
post-test research design was
used. 30 Children between (2-5 yrs) who underwent surgery and admitted in post
operative ward during the study period and who fulfilled the inclusion criteria
were selected. The subjects were selected by convenience sampling. The
questionnaire had the following items. Part one comprised of socio-demographic
variables such as age, sex, type of surgery, no of post operation day. Part two
comprised of FLACC behavioural pain assessment scale
to assess post operative pain in children. The acronym FLACC represents five
categories face, leg, activity, cry, consol ability. The pain was assessed using observation method responses in each
category are scored between 0 and 2 for a max total score of 10. Descriptive
statistics (frequency and percentage) and inferential statistics (chi square),
paired t test were used to analyze the study findings.
RESULTS:
Out of 30
subjects studied majority14 [46.67] children had moderate level of pain, 9[30]
experienced severe pain, 7[23.3] experienced mild pain. The mean score of
children before play therapy was 5.2[S.D1.98] and after play therapy was0.93
[S.D 1.046] .Paired’ value 20.28 significant at≤0.05 level. Hence it is
inferred that play therapy is effective. There was no significant relationship
between post operative pain and demographic variables.
DISCUSSION:
A total of 30
samples that fulfilled the inclusion criteria were selected and data were
gathered from them Majority 9 (30%) children were 4 yrs, 8 (26.67%) were 2 and
5 yrs children and 5 (16.66%) were 3 yrs children. Regarding sex majority 26
(86.67%) were male children and 4 (13.33%) were female children. Most of the
children numbering 27 (90%) underwent congenital anomaly correction surgeries.
2 (6.67%) children underwent other surgery and 1(3.33%) child underwent
abdominal surgery. Regarding the post operative day majority 26 (86.67%)
children come under 1st post operative day and the remaining 4
(13.33%) children on 2nd post operative day. Out of 30 subjects
studied a majority 14 (46.67%) children had moderate level of pain, 9 (30%)
children experienced severe pain. 7 (23.3%) children experienced mild pain. The
mean score of children before play therapy (n=30) was 5.2 (S.D 1.98) and the
mean score of children after play therapy n=30 was 0.93 (S.D 1.046). The obtained ‘t’
value is higher than the table value, ‘t’ = 20.28, P £ 0.05. This indicates that there was significant
reduction in pain scores and so the play therapy was effective. Maheswari (2003) in her study analysis has
concluded that there is effectiveness of play therapy in reducing the post
operative pain for children who had under gone minor surgeries. The obtained
chi-square value is less than table value at 0.05 levels. This shows that there
is no association between the post-operative pain and the selected demographic
variables. The investigator identified no association of pain with regard to
the child’s age. This may be due to the fact that even though pain is unique,
the younger children are not more conscious about their pain. Hence the
perception of pain intensity by them is similar. A study conducted by Schumacher and Vande Wijngaar found
that the pain intensity is not age related A similar study conducted by Goodenough et al., suggests that no sex
difference exists in young children’s ratings of pain intensity and
unpleasantness. Hamers et al. found that the more
severe the diagnosis the more inclined the nurses were to assess the pain
experience as more severe and consequently to justify the administration of an
analgesic.
Implications:
Behavioural techniques like
distraction, imaginative involvement should be used in the management of pain.
They can be used independently or in conjunction with drug therapy. Toys can be
provided to the child undergoing a painful procedure in order to divert the
child from painful sensation the nursing personnel have to plan and allot time
everyday to provide play for children. Comprehensive
assessment of the pain of infants and children with special emphasis on play
therapy need to be incorporated in nursing curriculum Update the nurse’s
knowledge about current practices and treatment through workshop and conferences
Though many studies are done in this concept in other countries. Such studies
need to be undertaken in India in future.
REFERENCES:
1.
Abbot K. (1990) Therapeutic use of play in the psychological
preparation of preschool children undergoing cardiac surgery Issues comprehensive pediatrics nursing
13(4): 265-77
2.
Adele Pillitteri (2007), Maternal and
Child Health Nursing 5th Edition. Philadelphia. Lippincott Williams and Wilkins (1095-1104. 1159-1176)
3.
Cecily Lynn Betz et.al., Family Centered
Nursing Care of children. 2nd edition Philadelphia W.B. Saunders
pg.(620-625)
4.
Christine Greco, M.D. et.al., (2005) Pain management for hospitalized patient pediatric
clinics of North America 52(4) 995-102.
Received on 03.03.2014 Modified on 02.05.2014
Accepted on 05.06.2014 ©
A&V Publication all right reserved
Asian J. Nur. Edu. & Research 4(3): July- Sept., 2014; Page 288-289